Post Details

Being profitable is hardly the evidence of a good business Author: Fintuned | Date: August 28, 2018

Reproduced from the blog jaagrav by our dear friend Vikas Agarwala The blog was posted by him on August 19, 2018. Watch out for more articles from him only on Fintuned 

Profit or Earnings Per Share (‘EPS’) is just an illusion. However, it is still considered a holy grail and sought-after number, tracked by most analysts. I have often wondered WhyProfit/Loss emanating from Profit & Loss Statement or EPS does NOT take 3 elements into consideration:

  • Principal Repayment of loan / debt, if any (gets featured in Cash Flow from Financing)
  • Capital expenditure required for long-term functioning and growth of the business
  • Working capital required for daily operations of the business

Looking at ITC and Tata Motors resulted in some interesting findings:

ITC during the last 17 years has had cumulative profit of INR 91,289 crores, Tata Motors during the same corresponding period has had cumulative profit of INR 93,314 crores. Considering that each of these companies have had approximately similar amount of profit during the period,

One may tend to believe that with equivalent profitability, both the companies would be valued similarly. Alas, this is not usually true.

ITC’s market capitalization rose by INR 300,000 crores during the 17-year period as compared to a mere INR 100,000 crores increase for Tata Motors, 200% more than a company having equal earnings for the same period.

While ITC invested close to INR 48,000 crores in the business over the last 17 years, Tata Motors during the same period invested close to INR 180,000 crores. So technically, with every INR 1 rupee of capital employed by ITC, it was able to generate profit of INR 1.90, whereas for every INR 1 rupee of capital employed by Tata Motors, it generated profit of merely INR 0.50.

Now, comes the interesting part, ITC has not had any external capital requirement during this period, i.e. the entire investment was funded by the cash flows being generated out of the business over the course of time.

Tata Motors, on the other hand has had dependency on external capital, to the tune of approximately INR 86,000 crores during the corresponding period. (Increase in Gross Debt during the period) Out of INR 180,000 crores of capital being employed in the business during the said period, 48% (INR 86,000 crores) had been funded by debt. This clearly demonstrates that while the company made profits, capital and working capital expenditure was higher, hence requirement of external capital.

Leveraging one’s business may generate profit in the short-run, however, without adequate cash flows, the business would ultimately collapse.

ITC generated Free Cash Flow of approx. INR 69,000 crores during the period as compared to Tata Motors which incurred negative FCF (INR 27,500) crores during the same corresponding period; i.e. capital expenditure and working capital needs were more than the cash flow from operations.

Next time, somebody rattles about profit or EPS, please do not permit that number to warp your judgement.

Note: Please note that these are his personal views. He is NOT a registered Research Analyst as per SEBI (Research Analyst) Regulations, 2014. All investors are advised to conduct their own independent research into individual stocks or industries before making any decision. In addition, investors are advised that past stock performance is not indicative of future price action. 


Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy of any agency, organization, employer, or any company. Fintuned Co. LLP shall not be held responsible in any manner whatsover, for any decision/action taken by readers on the basis of the content mentioned in the article. Readers are requested to exercise their best judgement before taking any decision/action. Fintuned Co. LLP shall also not be held responsible for any copyright infringement committed by the author in the process of writing and/or publishing this article and in the event any such offence is found, cooperate with necessary authorities to take remedial action


    0 comment found

Leave a Reply

Latest Posts




Hey wait,

Don't Disappoint your Coffee! Give it a good companion

Subscribe to stay updated! We promise we are too lazy to spam!